The more I read, the more society’s filter bubble problems
seem to be a sort of curse of convenience. In a world where an online identity
is completely made up of wants, the trend seems to be towards instant
gratification and away from awareness, curiosity, and discovery. I start to
think of the movie Wall-E and the people in their floating chairs that don’t
bother to move because they have perfected the fulfillment of want to the point where should is no longer desirable and
therefore no longer relevant. This personalization epidemic seems like such a
selfish affliction created simply because people are smothering themselves with
their own desires for convenience and immediacy.
Pariser’s
attitude towards those trapped in filter bubbles seems to be that of a shepherd
towards a wandering flock. He is genuinely concerned about and interested in
the status of modern society online; his work is a gentle wake-up call and
warning to many people (including myself). In talking about problems and
solutions of the filter bubble, however, he seems to illustrate every person in
possession of an online account the same way. Pariser speaks of filter bubble
occupants as a mass or flock that have been lead down a dicey path and need to
be escorted in a different direction. He is not incorrect or mean at all in
this view, but it does reveal a certain lack of faith in the individual to
break free of these bubbles. I’d like to have more hope in humanity’s general
competence level than that.
Ha! Great minds and all that: I kept thinking of Wall-E too. Somehow I think the makers of that (truly wonderful) film had read this book.
ReplyDeleteExcept that it came out in 2008. Maybe Eli Pariser was influenced by the film. ...
ReplyDelete